Caleb Downs
Ohio State
Consensus Rank
8
Colors: elite (top 10%)·strong·weak·bottom 10%all within S cohort (n=36)
NFL.com
6.47
ACS
—
40
4.99
HT
5'12"
WT
206
Arm
30.3
PFF Col
87.5
Mock→
—
Flags
1
Visits
3
Bench —
Vert —
Broad —
3c —
Shut —
Hand 9.5
Age —
Measurables
HT (in)71.63
WT (lb)206
Arm30.25
Hand9.50
404.99
Bench—
Vert—
Broad—
3-cone—
Shuttle—
By Source
nfl.com
armInches30.25
athleticismScore75.90
forty4.99
handInches9.50
heightInches71.63
weightLbs206
redflag-injury
CTE-11
Teams That Have Engaged (3)
Red Flags (1)
Extracted from Brugler background/weakness sections.
injury
- Most expected him to return home and join Kirby Smart’s Bulldogs, especially after Georgia hired his Alabama position coach (Travaris Robinson).
Historical Projection
based on 2006-2024 draft outcomes (n≈72 per attribute · confidence medium)Composite
37
0-100 scale
Expected career AV: 27.2
Attribute Contributions
- Shuttler=+0.40—z=—+0.0
- Draft ager=+0.25—z=—+0.0
- 3-coner=+0.23—z=—+0.0
- 40-yardr=-0.114.99z=-5.64+6.2
- Bench repsr=-0.10—z=—+0.0
- Verticalr=+0.08—z=—+0.0
- Heightr=+0.0771.63z=-0.46-0.3
- Broad jumpr=+0.01—z=—+0.0
- Weightr=+0.00206z=-0.03-0.0
PFF College — Opponent-Adjusted
Overall87.5
Pass Rush62.9
Run Defense83.3
Coverage89.6
Scouting Dossier
PFF
Downs lacks elite size or athletic traits, but his football IQ is exceptional. That gives him a high floor and ceiling, with All-Pro potential in a versatile defensive role.
Strengths
● Rangy, physical presence and drops the hammer on arrival
● Full-speed tackler with outstanding balance and twitch to break down in space
● Wraps, keeps his eyes before his feet and accelerates through target
● Quick to read keys and fly to the football from anywhere
● Dissects route combinations almost instantaneously for breakups or minimal post-catch gains
● Shows read-react burst of a cornerback when driving on throws
● Didn’t allow a passing touchdown in two seasons at Ohio State (874 coverage snaps)
● Balances high-level intelligence with disciplined decision-making
● Veteran-level communication skills
● Played on both punt return and punt coverages — had a 79-yard return touchdown versus Indiana in 2024
● Elite competitive toughness; voted one of four team captains in 2025
● Teammates praised his all-business attitude toward practice and meetings (NFL scout: “Our coaches are going to love him because
he’s a process guy — how he prepares influences how he plays.”)
● Proven to be durable — didn’t miss a game in his three college seasons
Weaknesses
● Doesn’t have the frame some desire at the position
● Kept everything top-down and was rarely asked to turn his back to the line
● Always around the football but posted mediocre ball production
● Does a great job reading routes and the quarterback but would like to see him take more chances
● Can occasionally misjudge open-field speed in pursuit angles
Projection
A two-year starter at Ohio State (and three-year starter overall), Downs played a variety of safety positions (STAR, money, post) in
defensive coordinator Matt Patricia’s scheme, which uses a lot of disguises and trap/zone coverages. He often aligned in split-safety
looks, where he could work down to create an eight-man box or drop into five-under man. Downs played with an unbelievable level of
consistency over his three years in college. He became the first freshman to lead Alabama in tackles in 2023, then was a two-time
unanimous All-American for the Buckeyes as he filled up his trophy case, including the 2024 national championship.
A human missile, Downs jumps off the tape because of his fast, competitive play style. Despite having average size, he is an elite tackler
who fills with impressive body control and strength at contact. He was most productive downhill and near the line of scrimmage but
showed the same high-level reaction skills in coverage. His pattern recognition and situational awareness are above average, although
you’d wish there was more ball production on his resume. Overall, Downs sees the field like it’s a chess board and plays with
an exceptional combination of intelligence, urgency and toughness, allowing him to be disruptive from anywhere on
the field. His intangibles and on-field versatility will make him an impactful NFL starter early in his career.
Mock Ranks (5)
- lance-zierlein-mock-2.19
- charles-davis-mock-3.010
- mel-kiper-big-board6
- daniel-jeremiah-4.09
- MDD-consensus8
Freak Notes
- none
Best Team Fits
Open in Fit Engine →- no fits scored yet